I've been told I have gallstones but I feel fine. Do I need an operation?
No. Silent gallstones found incidentally on a scan need no treatment. Only a minority go on to cause symptoms, and surgery carries its own risks, so watchful waiting is the correct approach. Being told you have gallstones is not the same as being told you need them removed.
What does a gallstone attack actually feel like?
Severe, constant pain in the upper abdomen — usually on the right — typically starting one to two hours after a fatty meal, lasting from thirty minutes to several hours, often radiating to the right shoulder blade, with nausea and vomiting. Despite being called "biliary colic", it does not come in waves. It builds, plateaus and then eases, and you feel entirely normal in between.
Can I avoid surgery with diet?
A lower-fat diet genuinely reduces how often attacks happen, and regular meals help. But it does not dissolve the stones, and once attacks have started they usually keep coming. Diet is a holding measure. The risk of waiting is that a planned day-case operation becomes an emergency admission with cholecystitis or pancreatitis.
Does the olive oil and lemon juice flush work?
No. The green-brown objects passed afterwards have been analysed many times: they are soap, formed when the oil reacts with digestive juices in the gut. They contain no cholesterol or bilirubin, and the same objects form in a jar outside the body. Worse, a large fat load in someone with gallstones can trigger a genuine attack or dislodge a stone — people have ended up in emergency surgery after trying one.
Can I live without a gallbladder?
Yes, entirely normally. The gallbladder stores and concentrates bile, but the liver keeps producing it and it simply flows continuously into the bowel instead. Most people notice no difference and can eat normally, though it is sensible to reintroduce fatty foods gradually in the first few weeks.
I keep getting diarrhoea since my gallbladder was removed.
Common, treatable, and frequently mislabelled as IBS. It is usually bile acid malabsorption — bile now flowing continuously into the bowel rather than in controlled amounts — and it responds dramatically to a bile acid binder such as colestyramine. A great many people put up with this for years without being told it has a name and a treatment.
Could my weight-loss injection have caused this?
It may have contributed, and we would rather be straightforward about it. Rapid weight loss — from any cause, including GLP-1 medications like tirzepatide and semaglutide — increases gallstone formation, because more cholesterol enters the bile and the gallbladder empties less often. It is a recognised effect. It does not mean stopping treatment is automatically right, but it does mean losing weight steadily, not skipping meals entirely, and telling us about any severe upper abdominal pain.
My liver tests were normal, so it can't be gallstones?
Not so — liver function tests are usually normal in straightforward biliary colic and do not exclude gallstones. They become abnormal when a stone moves into the bile duct. Ultrasound is the test that finds stones in the gallbladder, and it should be done fasted.
Why does it hurt in my shoulder?
Referred pain. The gallbladder and the skin over the right shoulder blade share nerve supply through the diaphragm, so the brain interprets the signal as coming from the shoulder. It is one of the most characteristic features of biliary pain and is genuinely useful in making the diagnosis.