What must I not ignore?
Sciatica in both legs, numbness in the saddle area, any change in bladder or bowel control, or new loss of sexual sensation. That is cauda equina syndrome, and it is an emergency — A&E immediately, not tomorrow. Delay of hours can cause permanent damage. A foot that is beginning to drag also needs assessing within days.
How long will this take?
Longer than you want, but it does resolve. Around three-quarters of people improve substantially within about twelve weeks without surgery, and herniated disc material frequently shrinks by itself — the bigger the herniation, the more likely. A good sign of progress is the pain retreating from the foot back up towards the buttock, even if the back feels worse for a while.
Should I rest?
No — rest makes sciatica last longer. Keep gently moving within what you can tolerate, walk rather than sit, and change position often. Prolonged sitting and driving are usually the worst things for it. The instinct to lie still is understandable and unhelpful.
I'm on pregabalin for this. Should I be?
Probably not. National guidance specifically advises against gabapentin and pregabalin for sciatica — the trials show little benefit while dizziness, drowsiness, weight gain and dependence are real. They are still widely prescribed for it. It is worth reviewing, and coming off them should be done gradually rather than abruptly.
Do I need an MRI?
Usually not, at least at first. It does not change treatment in the early weeks, and disc bulges appear on the scans of large numbers of people with no symptoms at all. An MRI is warranted where surgery or an injection is being considered, where there is significant weakness, where there is a red flag, or where symptoms persist beyond about three months.
Will I need surgery?
Most people do not. Where sciatica is severe and persistent beyond several weeks, and the MRI matches the symptoms, discectomy relieves leg pain faster than continuing to wait — though outcomes at one year are similar either way. That is the honest trade-off: surgery buys speed rather than a better final result, which is worth knowing when deciding.
Has my disc slipped out of place?
No — the term is misleading. Discs do not slip. Part of the softer inner material pushes out through the tougher outer ring and irritates the nerve, both by pressing on it and by inflaming it. Nothing is out of position, and nothing needs putting back.
What is the difference between sciatica and ordinary back pain?
Sciatica is leg pain worse than back pain, usually travelling below the knee, often with pins and needles or numbness, and typically shooting when you cough or sneeze. Buttock pain that stops above the knee and aches rather than shoots is usually referred pain rather than true sciatica — a distinction that changes both the treatment and the outlook.