Do I definitely have a fungal infection?
Not necessarily — up to half of thickened, discoloured nails are not fungal. Repeated trauma from footwear and psoriasis both look very similar. This matters because oral treatment means months of tablets, blood tests and drug interactions. Get a nail clipping tested before committing to any of that, and take the sample before starting any treatment.
Why does my nail still look awful after finishing the tablets?
Because that is expected. The treatment kills the fungus but the damaged nail has to grow out, and a toenail takes 12 to 18 months to replace itself. Judge it by whether healthy nail is appearing at the base, not by the tip. This is far and away the commonest reason people think treatment failed when it did not.
Does the nail paint work?
Rarely, if the infection is established. Cure rates for amorolfine lacquer are well under a third, and it only really works for early infection at the tip of one or two nails without involvement of the base. We would rather tell you that than take a year of your effort. Filing the nail surface first helps a little.
Do I have to treat it?
No. If the nail is painless and does not bother you, leaving it is entirely reasonable — months of tablets for an appearance problem is a real trade-off. It becomes more important if you have diabetes, poor circulation or a weakened immune system, where thickened nails and athlete's foot together can lead to skin breaks and infection.
Why does it keep coming back?
Almost always because the skin was not treated. Athlete's foot is the reservoir — treat it alongside and keep treating it. And use an antifungal powder inside your shoes: fungal spores survive in footwear for months, and this step is nearly always missed.
I have a dark line down one nail. Is that fungal?
Not usually, and it needs looking at rather than treating. A brown or black lengthways streak in a single nail — especially one that is widening, distorting the nail, or spreading onto the skin at the cuticle — can be a melanoma of the nail. Please get it assessed promptly rather than waiting to see whether it grows out.
Can I still paint my nails?
Not while you are treating them — varnish, gel and acrylics all seal moisture against the nail and work against you. Once treatment is finished and healthy nail is growing, it is fine. And at a salon, check the instruments are properly sterilised between clients, or take your own — nail bars are a genuine source of infection.